from today's New York Times
full article here. written by Dan Barry of the Times for the "About New York" column.
Professor Gurland of NYU's philosophy department once told my class that the true evil of the Holocaust or the Turkish genocide of the Armenians or any such act can only be measured if you consider what it would be like, how long it would take, to meet and shake the hand of every victim, to consider each individual affected, to turn the numbing numbers into individual people.
. . . . .
full article here. written by Dan Barry of the Times for the "About New York" column.
Professor Gurland of NYU's philosophy department once told my class that the true evil of the Holocaust or the Turkish genocide of the Armenians or any such act can only be measured if you consider what it would be like, how long it would take, to meet and shake the hand of every victim, to consider each individual affected, to turn the numbing numbers into individual people.
The other day Al and Ginger Petrocelli learned that some remains of their son, Mark, had been identified. Again. Which meant that it was time to visit the funeral home. Again. Time to cremate. Again.
This was the fifth time in the last two years that parts of Mark Petrocelli had been identified. Mark Petrocelli, 28: husband of Nicole, son of Al and Ginger, younger brother of Al Jr., uncle of Emily, friend of many. The fifth time.
[...]
"This time," the father said, "from his left knee down to the top of his foot. Right femur with right lower leg and kneecap. Some skin. A piece of skull bone. Soft tissue. Muscle."
[...]
The phrases we rely on to make sense of grief have always failed to convey the ache of the irreplaceable. But even with the grace of two years, the World Trade Center collapse continues to render meaningless such terms as "closure" and "moving on."
Acceptance may be a better word, acceptance of how the event has become incorporated in our everyday lives — in who we are. At least that is how your neighbors the Petrocellis see it. The Petrocellis, one wounded family among thousands.
[...]
Mark Petrocelli, a commodities trader for Carr Futures, was attending a meeting on the 92nd floor of the north tower, which says it all in the parlance of post-9/11.But the Petrocellis did not know this on that day. Al Petrocelli, a retired battalion chief with the Fire Department, and Al Jr., also a firefighter, raced to Lower Manhattan after the attack.
The father remembered feeling a can-do sense of mission, an echo from his days as a firefighter and as a soldier in Vietnam. "I thought that `I could go down there and I'll find Mark,' " he said. But reality set in with the rain that fell two days later, he said. "I came home and said, `No way.' "
[...]
On Sept. 25, 2001, the Petrocellis learned that Mark's death had been confirmed through dental records. On Oct. 26, they were told that his upper torso had been identified. On Nov. 11, some soft tissue and muscle. On March 21, 2002, four parts, including his heart.
"They found his heart," Mrs. Petrocelli said. "What do you say?"
This was the fifth time in the last two years that parts of Mark Petrocelli had been identified. Mark Petrocelli, 28: husband of Nicole, son of Al and Ginger, younger brother of Al Jr., uncle of Emily, friend of many. The fifth time.
[...]
"This time," the father said, "from his left knee down to the top of his foot. Right femur with right lower leg and kneecap. Some skin. A piece of skull bone. Soft tissue. Muscle."
[...]
The phrases we rely on to make sense of grief have always failed to convey the ache of the irreplaceable. But even with the grace of two years, the World Trade Center collapse continues to render meaningless such terms as "closure" and "moving on."
Acceptance may be a better word, acceptance of how the event has become incorporated in our everyday lives — in who we are. At least that is how your neighbors the Petrocellis see it. The Petrocellis, one wounded family among thousands.
[...]
Mark Petrocelli, a commodities trader for Carr Futures, was attending a meeting on the 92nd floor of the north tower, which says it all in the parlance of post-9/11.But the Petrocellis did not know this on that day. Al Petrocelli, a retired battalion chief with the Fire Department, and Al Jr., also a firefighter, raced to Lower Manhattan after the attack.
The father remembered feeling a can-do sense of mission, an echo from his days as a firefighter and as a soldier in Vietnam. "I thought that `I could go down there and I'll find Mark,' " he said. But reality set in with the rain that fell two days later, he said. "I came home and said, `No way.' "
[...]
On Sept. 25, 2001, the Petrocellis learned that Mark's death had been confirmed through dental records. On Oct. 26, they were told that his upper torso had been identified. On Nov. 11, some soft tissue and muscle. On March 21, 2002, four parts, including his heart.
"They found his heart," Mrs. Petrocelli said. "What do you say?"
for more on the two-year anniversary, visit "September 11, 2003" at The New York Times website.





